<- Back to Insights

Five Mistakes to Avoid in Leadership Transitions

Based on the firm's experience leading over 100 searches for nonprofit CEO placements.

Price Harding

Chairman

Article

As an executive search firm, CarterBaldwin has led more than 100 searches to find CEOs for the world's largest faith-based nonprofits. In every instance, there is a board strongly committed to the future of the institution, with intent to make the transition from the incumbent to the new leader as smooth as possible for the mission of the organization.

Here are five mistakes that boards should work hard to avoid:

1. Delegating Succession Planning to the CEO

Selecting the right leader is the most important responsibility of the board, and it should never be delegated to the incumbent leader.

2. Committing the Role to an Internal Person

While an internal person may ultimately be the best selection, the board should not be restricted to a choice of one.

3. Hiring in Reaction to the Incumbent

The board or search committee needs to think only about the organization's mission and future, and find the leader who can most likely bring that future to fruition.

4. Allowing the Philosophical to Conflict With the Practical

Do not expect a highly qualified external candidate to know the peculiarities of your organization as well as a possibly less qualified internal candidate.

5. Permitting the Incumbent to Determine His/Her Future Role

The board needs to define what role, if any, the incumbent leader will have in the administration of the new leader.

There is no greater gift to give to a departing leader than to cap his or her tenure with the assurance of the organization's continued success.

This article originally appeared in Evangelicals magazine.

Price Harding is the Chairman and Co-founder of CarterBaldwin Executive Search and currently serves on the Board of Trustees of The Heritage Foundation and the Trinity Forum.

More Insights

Article
CarterBaldwin Conversations: A Conversation with Dr. Nathan O. Hatch

April 30, 2026

By 

Discussion with former Wake Forest President about leadership transitions and team building practices.

Read the Article
Article
Succession Done Right: What Nonprofits Can Learn from the Leadership Transition at Cassia

April 2, 2026

Explores planning and intentional strategies for nonprofit leadership transitions using a senior living organization case study.

Read the Article
Podcast
Leadership Stability at HBCUs: Breaking the Cycle of Short Presidential Tenures

February 23, 2026

Discussion on presidential turnover challenges at Historically Black Colleges and Universities.

Listen to Podcast
Article
Breaking the Two-Year Cycle: Strengthening Presidential Tenure at HBCUs

October 15, 2025

Addresses the presidential turnover issue where the average HBCU president serves less than three years.

Read the Article
Article
CEO Onboarding for Nonprofit Boards: A Practical Guide to High-Trust Leadership Transitions

July 31, 2025

By 

Board-focused guide emphasizing onboarding's role in ensuring continuity and organizational success.

Read the Article
Article
The First 90 Days: How to Onboard a C-Suite Executive into a Privately-Held, Family-Owned Company

June 18, 2025

Explores critical onboarding steps for bringing external leaders into family businesses.

Read the Article
Article
Passing the Baton at Compassion International: A Model for CEO Transitions

May 4, 2025

By 

Features 2024 interviews providing a nonprofit transition roadmap emphasizing timing and preparation.

Read the Article
Article
Building on Legacy: The Leadership Transition at Our Daily Bread Ministries

April 2, 2025

By 

Examines how outgoing and incoming CEOs collaborate during nonprofit transitions.

Read the Article
Article
Candid Advice from the Head of School to the Board Chair

March 7, 2025

By 

Addresses declining tenure lengths in independent schools and stability solutions.

Read the Article
Article
The Head of School Interview: Navigating Key Questions

March 13, 2024

By 

Describes the interview process as a delicate dance for school leadership searches.

Read the Article
Podcast
Transforming Education: Unveiling the Power of Retained Search Firms in K-12 Leadership

December 5, 2023

By 

Explores retained search firms' role in finding culturally-aligned K-12 leaders.

Listen to Podcast
Podcast
Why Culture Matters

March 24, 2022

Podcast discussion on organizational culture impact from an energy/infrastructure sector perspective.

Listen to Podcast
Atlanta Office

100 Kimball Place
Suite 225
Alpharetta, Georgia 30009

‍Map & Directions

678-448-0000

Washington DC Office

1015 18th Street, NW
Suite 201
Washington, DC 20036

‍Map & Directions

Birmingham Office

4553 Pine Tree Circle
Vestavia Hills, AL 35243

‍Map & Directions

© Copyright 2026 | CarterBaldwin Executive Search | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy