<- Back to Insights

The Talent to Differentiate

Examines market shifts in tax and accounting industries and competitive pressures on regional firms.

David Clapp

Managing Partner

Article

The tax, accounting and consulting market has experienced seismic shifts in recent years.  Several factors have played into the fast rate of change, including continued economic uncertainty, earnings pressure, aggressive federal and state tax jurisdictions, global regulatory change and more aggressive competition between firms.  Regional firms are pushing up market.  National firms are breaking the old rules, pushing down market and more willing to use price as a lever to win business.  New firm starts, M&A activity in the space, and heavy movement of people between firms offers more options for clients.

Professional service firms are increasingly forced to become serious about competing. And while clients are benefiting from the competitive forces at work, it also is more challenging for them to discern differences between the firms.  Recently, a good friend who is CFO of a large international corporation and a former VP of Tax of a global telecom giant told me that he’s had countless tax and accounting partners and senior managers call on him over the years, yet “none of the firms were memorable.”  His comment points to a very real issue (or opportunity)-the need to differentiate.  Without differentiation, service lines become commoditized, price pressure creeps in and client loyalty can wane.

Blurring between firms has occurred as many took an opportunistic approach to the availability of talent as Andersen went away and the consulting practices of other firms were spun out.  SOX created structural change, causing many to change their strategies for selling tax services, driving tax people into the market and to different firms.  New practices were “bolted on,” and the partner and professional ranks changed across many firms.  One firm’s loss quickly became another’s gain.  What has emerged in many instances is a loose confederation of practice areas under an umbrella firm name, with many losing some of their identity and uniqueness and looking from the outside like “one-stop shops” for consulting, advisory and tax services.  Remove logos and names, and it’s a sea of sameness.

This is where we as professional service people can take a lesson from the consumer products folks. Differentiation, positioning and branding are terms frequently heard in the halls of MBA schools and consumer product companies.  While consumer marketing can’t be holistically applied to service firms, the principles are transferable: being different, better, special and memorable yields competitive advantage, growth, sustainability and higher margins.

Great consumer products companies are intentional and vigilant about telling a consistent story of how they are unique, and they do so at every touch point (packaging, advertising, promotions, etc.).  Unlike consumer products though, branding and differentiation for professional service firms is driven largely by their people. Unfortunately, many tax, accounting and consulting professionals don’t have their arms around why their firm is different, better and special; thus, when the gun goes off every morning and the people hit the streets, the firm’s marketing gets muddled.

When I ask many leaders why their firm is special, all too often I hear “we have the best people” or “we have more partner involvement at lower rates.”  These are not defensible, sustainable or unique positions for professional service firms.  Not surprisingly, further down the ranks, many can espouse why they are great as individual practitioners but struggle to answer the question, “Why my firm over another.” It would make me uncomfortable as a managing partner if my team only emphasized their particular specialty or ability and could not compellingly articulate why the firm was different, better and special.

It is incumbent on firm leadership to verbalize the answer to the “why us” question, then ensure their people, culture, operating systems and pricing line up and reinforce that answer. On the people side, leadership needs to ensure they build their ranks with practice leaders and partners that sell and deliver in a way that builds firm equity.  Opportunistic hiring can be great, but in recent years many have approached this process with a mind toward short term growth that is attached to an individual practitioner, gaining some quick revenue hits but diluting the firm’s unique identity and becoming “commoditized” in the longer run.

The best market-facing reputation builders, especially at the practice leader level need to be better than just “functionally” strong with good closing skill.  High business acumen, culturally and aspirationally aligned leaders are necessary to build and differentiate the firm as well as their practice.  This alignment between a partner’s specialty area, experience and wiring and that of their firm is the key that leads to revenue and margin growth and delighted, long term “sticky” clients.  It completes the story of why the partner and the firm are a unique, good fit for the client, and creates scalability for the firm beyond the individual partner’s book of business.

Achieving this requires great intentionality by leadership about the unique, differentiated place in the market they want their firm to occupy. Then it requires equally intentional recruiting and deployment of well-aligned practice leaders and partners into the market who can tell, sell and deliver accordingly.  Some firms are doing this very well … others still have an opportunity.  Getting serious about being different, better and special is heavy lifting but it yields great long-term value for the firm and its clients.

More Insights

Article
CarterBaldwin Conversations: A Conversation with Dr. Nathan O. Hatch

April 30, 2026

By 

Discussion with former Wake Forest President about leadership transitions and team building practices.

Read the Article
Article
Succession Done Right: What Nonprofits Can Learn from the Leadership Transition at Cassia

April 2, 2026

Explores planning and intentional strategies for nonprofit leadership transitions using a senior living organization case study.

Read the Article
Podcast
Leadership Stability at HBCUs: Breaking the Cycle of Short Presidential Tenures

February 23, 2026

Discussion on presidential turnover challenges at Historically Black Colleges and Universities.

Listen to Podcast
Article
Breaking the Two-Year Cycle: Strengthening Presidential Tenure at HBCUs

October 15, 2025

Addresses the presidential turnover issue where the average HBCU president serves less than three years.

Read the Article
Article
CEO Onboarding for Nonprofit Boards: A Practical Guide to High-Trust Leadership Transitions

July 31, 2025

By 

Board-focused guide emphasizing onboarding's role in ensuring continuity and organizational success.

Read the Article
Article
The First 90 Days: How to Onboard a C-Suite Executive into a Privately-Held, Family-Owned Company

June 18, 2025

Explores critical onboarding steps for bringing external leaders into family businesses.

Read the Article
Article
Passing the Baton at Compassion International: A Model for CEO Transitions

May 4, 2025

By 

Features 2024 interviews providing a nonprofit transition roadmap emphasizing timing and preparation.

Read the Article
Article
Building on Legacy: The Leadership Transition at Our Daily Bread Ministries

April 2, 2025

By 

Examines how outgoing and incoming CEOs collaborate during nonprofit transitions.

Read the Article
Article
Candid Advice from the Head of School to the Board Chair

March 7, 2025

By 

Addresses declining tenure lengths in independent schools and stability solutions.

Read the Article
Article
The Head of School Interview: Navigating Key Questions

March 13, 2024

By 

Describes the interview process as a delicate dance for school leadership searches.

Read the Article
Podcast
Transforming Education: Unveiling the Power of Retained Search Firms in K-12 Leadership

December 5, 2023

By 

Explores retained search firms' role in finding culturally-aligned K-12 leaders.

Listen to Podcast
Podcast
Why Culture Matters

March 24, 2022

Podcast discussion on organizational culture impact from an energy/infrastructure sector perspective.

Listen to Podcast
Atlanta Office

100 Kimball Place
Suite 225
Alpharetta, Georgia 30009

‍Map & Directions

678-448-0000

Washington DC Office

1015 18th Street, NW
Suite 201
Washington, DC 20036

‍Map & Directions

Birmingham Office

4553 Pine Tree Circle
Vestavia Hills, AL 35243

‍Map & Directions

© Copyright 2026 | CarterBaldwin Executive Search | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy