<- Back to Insights

Passing the Baton at Compassion International: A Model for CEO Transitions

Features 2024 interviews providing a nonprofit transition roadmap emphasizing timing and preparation.

Bill Peterson

Partner

Article

A smooth CEO transition in a nonprofit should resemble the precision of a relay race — timing, trust, and preparation are key. Compassion International's CEO transition provides a roadmap for nonprofit boards navigating leadership changes, regardless of organizational size.

In 2024, we interviewed Judy Golz and Karen Wesolowski, current and former board chairs, respectively, alongside former CEO Wess Stafford and his successor Jimmy Mellado. Their insights reveal a well-executed transition built on early planning, collaboration, and humility.

Summary of Compassion's Best Practices:

  1. Begin succession planning early. A structured framework ensures a calm, deliberate process rather than a reactive, crisis-driven transition.
  2. Involve key stakeholders to reduce uncertainty and build buy-in.
  3. Evaluate both internal and external candidates, prioritizing mission alignment and leadership capabilities.
  4. Interview and select a qualified executive search consultant that brings significant experience in the sector and access to a broader relational network.
  5. Establish clear protocols to prevent ambiguity. The outgoing leader's role should support—not overshadow—the new CEO.
  6. Structured onboarding should include overlapping leadership periods, formal endorsement from the outgoing leader, and board oversight.
  7. A public transition ceremony reinforces unity and continuity.
  8. Outgoing leaders should release control, while incoming leaders should approach their role as servant-leaders.
  9. Prioritize donor communications during leadership transitions.
  10. Outgoing leaders should use their influence to build trust in the new leader by affirming their successors publicly and privately.
  11. Clearly define emeritus roles and ensure they align with board-approved expectations.
  12. Protect organizational stability by encouraging new leaders to focus on trust-building and cultural integration before implementing change.
  13. Implement regular performance reviews to track leadership effectiveness.
  14. Build leadership development into the organization's long-term strategy.

By following the best practices modeled by Compassion and its leaders, nonprofits can confidently navigate leadership transitions. Compassion International's approach underscores the importance of proactive planning, collaboration, and humility and how adopting these principles can ensure a smooth transition that sustains and advances an organization's mission.

For more information, contact Bill Peterson at bpeterson@carterbaldwin.com.

More Insights

Article
Text vs. Email: Seven Reasons Why Email (Still) Reigns in Business Communications

December 15, 2020

By 

Discusses business communication preferences in remote work environments.

Read the Article
Article
An Impromptu Conversation with our Managing Partner, David Clapp, on our Culture and Core Values

September 11, 2020

By 

Managing Partner David Clapp discusses company culture with an entrepreneur and investor.

Read the Article
Article
Managing Culture in Chaos

June 17, 2020

Addresses maintaining organizational culture during unprecedented disruption.

Read the Article
Article
Building Culture Amidst the Storm

June 1, 2020

Features nonprofit leaders discussing remote work culture strategies during the pandemic.

Read the Article
Article
The Single Most Important Role of a CEO

October 2, 2017

Explores what the firm believes is the CEO's primary responsibility among many competing demands.

Read the Article
Article
The Zone of Pressure vs. the Zone of Contentment

June 8, 2016

Discusses aligning teams and resources to maximize the odds of organizational success.

Read the Article
Article
Measuring Trust

June 8, 2016

Addresses four critical components the firm evaluates when determining executive fit for leadership roles.

Read the Article
Article
The Talent to Differentiate

June 7, 2016

By 

Examines market shifts in tax and accounting industries and competitive pressures on regional firms.

Read the Article
Article
When Servant Leadership becomes…Leader Servantship

June 6, 2016

A personal narrative reflecting on leadership philosophy through a Sunday School teaching experience.

Read the Article
Article
Top 10 Reasons to Consider External Candidates

June 6, 2016

Presents arguments for recruiting outside leadership while acknowledging the importance of internal promotions.

Read the Article
Article
The Decision to Hire – Not a "No-Brainer"

June 6, 2016

Uses a case study to illustrate complexities in hiring decisions for new organizational roles.

Read the Article
Article
A Talent Shortage Still Exists for Business-Minded Professionals

June 4, 2016

Notes a persistent leadership shortage combining technical expertise with strategic business acumen.

Read the Article
Atlanta Office

100 Kimball Place
Suite 225
Alpharetta, Georgia 30009

‍Map & Directions

678-448-0000

Washington DC Office

1015 18th Street, NW
Suite 201
Washington, DC 20036

‍Map & Directions

Birmingham Office

4553 Pine Tree Circle
Vestavia Hills, AL 35243

‍Map & Directions

© Copyright 2026 | CarterBaldwin Executive Search | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy